Pastoral search • McConnelsville, Ohio

A faithful history.
A hopeful future.

We’re seeking our next pastor—someone to walk with us, lead with a shepherd’s heart, and help us share the love of Jesus.

For 200 years, faith has brought people together here. As an independent congregation in the historic Wesleyan tradition, we are prayerfully looking toward our next chapter of worship, discipleship, and service.

McConnelsville Methodist Church in autumn
McConnelsville Methodist Church
1826Our congregation established
45–60Typical Sunday attendance*Average age: approximately 71
9:00 a.m.Sunday blended worship
Full-timePastoral position available

*From the approved congregational profile revised November 16, 2026.

Meet our church family

Rooted in Scripture.
Ready to grow.

McConnelsville Methodist Church is a joyful, welcoming congregation with a heart for Jesus and our neighbors. We gather across generations, value the gifts of lay leaders, and believe that ministry belongs to the whole church family.

Our recent journey has led us to become an independent church while retaining our Wesleyan heritage. Jesus Christ is the Head of our church, and Holy Scripture is our final authority for faith and practice.

We have committed lay leadership, a welcoming spirit, and meaningful community relationships upon which to build. We seek a compassionate, collaborative pastor who will honor our heritage, equip our people for ministry, and guide thoughtful change as we reach our neighbors for Christ.

Worshiping together
Worshiping together
Our mission

“Sharing the Love of Jesus
to Transform Lives.”

Bible Truth. Life Together. Team Jesus.

Faith that shapes our life

What holds us together

Our church profile describes a biblical, Christ-centered faith expressed through worship, compassionate care, and a pioneering spirit.

Jesus at the center

We confess Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior and believe salvation is God’s gift, received by grace through repentance and faith in Him.

Wesleyan roots

We value scriptural holiness, growth in Christlike love, prayer, accountability, and faithful stewardship.

Faith in action

We want our worship and discipleship to lead us outward—loving our neighbors, serving vulnerable people, and sharing the Gospel.

Read more about our beliefs

We believe in one God—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit—and receive the Bible as the complete, true, and holy Word of God. We celebrate Holy Baptism and Holy Communion, with an open Communion table for all who seek Jesus and desire peace with God and neighbor.

The complete church profile includes our Statement of Faith, biblical convictions, Wesleyan heritage, and governance overview. Candidates should review the full document for theological alignment.

Download the approved November 2026 profile
Real people. Shared faith.

A glimpse of life together

These are the faces and moments of our church family: gathering for worship, learning about Jesus, sharing meals, and encouraging one another.

The pastoral opportunity

Lead with faith.
Serve with love.

We are seeking a full-time pastor with a shepherd’s heart and a strong grounding in Wesleyan theology—someone who will build relationships, develop disciples, and help connect generations. We recognize the need to connect with younger generations while continuing to nurture those who have faithfully sustained this church.

The ministry we envision

  • Preach and teach Scripture with clarity, conviction, and practical application.
  • Offer compassionate pastoral care, visitation, and spiritual guidance.
  • Equip lay leaders and volunteers for shared ministry.
  • Encourage discipleship through prayer, Bible study, and Christian fellowship.
  • Lead worship services and administer ordinances in keeping with the church’s beliefs.
  • Help strengthen ministries and relationships across generations, including engagement with children, youth, and young families.

The leader we hope to welcome

  • A growing personal relationship with Jesus Christ, spiritual maturity, integrity, and healthy pastoral boundaries.
  • Theological alignment with our Statement of Faith and Wesleyan heritage.
  • A patient listener who builds trust across generations.
  • A collaborative servant leader who values lay involvement.
  • A hopeful, adaptable approach to change and growth.
  • A heart for McConnelsville and the people of Morgan County.

A home for your family and ministry

Church parsonage with warm autumn foliage
Our church parsonage • Optional housing

Our church offers a three-bedroom parsonage with an attached garage, built in 1998 and located next to the church. Parsonage maintenance and yardwork are covered. Living in the parsonage is optional; alternative housing arrangements can be discussed during the search process.

Education and experience

We welcome experienced pastors, associate pastors seeking a senior leadership opportunity, and qualified seminary graduates sensing God’s call to pastoral ministry.

Formal ministry training is preferred; strong biblical knowledge, ministry gifting, and evidence of God’s calling will also be carefully considered.

View / download job posting ↓
Our church tent at the July 4th Festival in downtown McConnelsville
Our church tent at the July 4th Festival in the heart of downtown McConnelsville
Church beyond the walls

A heart for our neighbors

Our outreach includes meals for Morgan High School sports teams, Operation Christmas Child shoeboxes, parking-lot fundraising opportunities for youth groups, and participation in village events.

We provide space for weekly AA, NA, and TOPS meetings and recently hosted one night of “Revival in the Hills,” a four-day, county-wide revival hosted by five churches with Scott Shipman, the “Disaster Pastor.” We hope our next pastor will help us strengthen these relationships and discern where God is calling us to serve next.

Sharing a meal with the Morgan High School basketball team—one of several high school sports teams we feed
Sharing a meal with the Morgan High School basketball team—one of several high school sports teams we feed
Operation Christmas Child shoeboxes packed in a vehicle for delivery
Operation Christmas Child shoeboxes—packed with love and ready to bless children around the world
A place to put down roots

Welcome to McConnelsville

A little river-town charm. A deeper sense of belonging.

Nestled along the Muskingum River in Morgan County, McConnelsville has a charm all its own—historic storefronts, hills that change with the seasons, and a pace that gives you room to notice it all. Here, a quick stop downtown can turn into a conversation, and a familiar face can soon become a friend.

We may not have the endless choices of a city, but our quaint river town offers its own kind of abundance: locally owned shops, hometown celebrations, neighbors cheering from the same bleachers, and people willing to lend a hand. Schools, local organizations, businesses, and churches help weave these connections into a community where relationships matter.

For someone drawn to small-town life, McConnelsville offers room to breathe, roots to grow, and opportunities to make a meaningful difference. There are families to support, older neighbors to care for, and practical needs to meet with compassion. For a pastor, ministry can begin with a simple hello—and grow into lasting relationships that bring Christ’s hope into everyday life.

A Sunday at MMC

9:00 a.m. • Blended worship with prayer, Scripture, congregational participation, and a message.

Children’s Church • Ages 3–12 begin with their families and head downstairs after the Children’s Message.

10:00 a.m. • Adult Sunday School in Morris Hall.

Coffee, conversation, and a warm welcome before and after worship.

Tuesday Bible Study • 2:30 p.m. in Morris Hall.

Begin a conversation

Could God be calling you here?

We invite you to prayerfully review the job posting and church profile. The position is open until filled.

How to apply

Please submit application materials to:

McConnelsville Methodist Church
Attn: SPRC – Todd Spence

98 N. 10th Street
McConnelsville, OH 43756

Email: mmc43756@gmail.com
Church office: 740-962-2285

Application materials

  • Résumé
  • Personal testimony
  • Statement of faith
  • Philosophy of ministry
  • Three references
  • Links to recent sermon recordings, if available
View / download job posting ↓Download church profile ↓